Home > 

3 pacers or 3 spinners Will India go with conditions or back their strengths for Dharamsala Test


As the Indian cricket team revels in securing the five-match Test series against England, a challenging predicament looms over the final Test at Dharamsala—the selection dilemma that hinges on the whims of weather and pitch conditions. While India may already boast a series victory, the stakes remain high due to the implications for the World Test Championship, lending every Test match a weight of significance. Taking a page from the weather’s playbook, the team management might be swayed to include a trio of pacers in the playing XI.

The skies over Dharamsala have been sodden with rain and the sun’s absence has left the pitch largely devoid of the cracks that spinners may exploit—a stark contrast to the customary subcontinental conditions. The overcast ambiance hints at a pitch that could facilitate substantial movement of the red cherry through the air, tempting strategists to lean toward a pace-centric attack.

Amid this backdrop, the focus is squarely on off-spinning stalwart Ravichandran Ashwin as he gears up for his milestone 100th Test match appearance. However, strategic decisions rest with captain Rohit Sharma and head coach Rahul Dravid, who are deliberating over possibly scaling back to a dual-spin attack if the current weather holds. Historical data from Ranji Trophy games on the ground buttresses the fast bowlers’ case—they have reaped 122 wickets in four matches at an average of 23.17, while the spinners have managed a paltry seven wickets at an average of 58.42.

Nonetheless, the tale of the tape presents a twist when reflecting on the lone Test previously played at this venue, a 2017 India-Australia clash, where spinners claimed 18 of the 32 wickets to fall. This statistic is accentuated by Australian spinner Nathan Lyon’s five-wicket haul from that match, although the pitch wasn’t particularly spinner-friendly. The international stage, it would seem, sometimes presents a contrasting narrative to domestic cricket when it comes to Dharamsala’s pitch.

Zeroing in on the composition of India’s squad for the upcoming match, it’s anticipated that the fiery Jasprit Bumrah is slated to replace Akash Deep. However, should the conditions cement the stance for three seamers, the selectors could find themselves in a tight spot. Kuldeep Yadav has recently impressed with the ball, and sidelining either of the spin virtuosos—Ashwin or Ravindra Jadeja—appears unlikely.

India’s playing XI, largely anticipated to be unchanged barring Bumrah’s inclusion, stands as follows: Rohit Sharma (C), Yashasvi Jaiswal, Shubman Gill, Rajat Patidar, Ravindra Jadeja, Sarfaraz Khan, Dhruv Jurel (WK), Ravichandran Ashwin, Jasprit Bumrah, Kuldeep Yadav, and Mohammed Siraj. This lineup fortifies a balanced attack encompassing both the guile of spin and the vigor of pace.

In the periphery of these game-time decisions, other cricketing narratives continue to unfold. The Delhi Capitals have jostled the Mumbai Indians down the points table, punctuating a streak-breaking victory. Ashwin’s reflections on his laudable spells—sans a fifer—counterpoints his impressive tally of 35 such achievements. Parallelly, ahead of the T20 World Cup, Pakistan cricketers prepare to infuse martial vigour into their training regimen, eyeing the army’s expertise to “hit big sixes.”

Each of these stories dances around the central theme of cricket’s unyielding demand for adaptability and strategy. As the lights fade on the penultimate day before the Dharamsala Test, the Indian team will have to weigh their strengths against the whispers of the conditions, charting a course that could consolidate their dominance or expose their vulnerabilities. The final decision is still up in the air, much like the overcast clouds that hover, both laden with the potential to influence the outcome of the game profoundly.