Home > 

If you are not using Siraj why not…: Ex-India opener suggests surprising change to playing XI for 2nd Test


The English cricket team landed a strong blow on Indian hopes with a surprising victory in the first Test at Hyderabad, rattling the host nation and securing a 1-0 lead in the five-match series. The defeat, however, wasn’t the only source of dismay for Team India. Injuries to KL Rahul and Ravindra Jadeja, who were pivotal in amassing runs in the first encounter, have left a conspicuous void. As the teams gear up for the second Test in Vizag, the Indian squad embarks on a recalibration with the assimilation of some quality players, even though their playing XI still grapples with questions on optimal balance amidst the absence of key contributors.

Traditionally, experts might dictate a like-for-like strategy to fill the gaps—slotting a middle-order batsman for Rahul and a spin-bowling all-rounder for Jadeja. Parthiv Patel, former India wicketkeeper-batsman, deviates from convention, proposing an unexpected lineup tweak. Sharing his insights on JioCinema, Patel highlighted the underutilization of pace bowler Mohammed Siraj, who bowled a mere 11 overs and went wicketless at his home ground in Hyderabad. His suggestion? Replace a pacer with an extra batsman.

“There is no doubt that three spinners are enough, but I have a different perspective. You have used Siraj for only six or seven overs throughout the Test. Axar Patel played ahead of Kuldeep Yadav because of his batting abilities, as mentioned by Rohit Sharma before the Test. And if you are not using Siraj much, then why not play an extra pure batter,” Parthiv articulated.

Parthiv’s unorthodox proposition involves forgoing a spin-bowling all-rounder for the inclusion of both a specialist batsman and a dedicated spinner in Kuldeep Yadav, thus favoring the balance of the batting depth over the pace attack. “So, you will have three types of bowlers in Ashwin, Axar, and Kuldeep, and the extra batter will add depth to the batting. And there’s no point playing someone if you are going to give him only seven overs,” he elaborated.

If the Indian team management is swayed by this tactical blueprint, possible beneficiaries could be Rajat Patidar and Sarfaraz Khan, who might be poised to don the Indian whites for the first time in Vizag, more so since stalwart Virat Kohli will also sit out the second Test. However, integration of two novices in the same facet may be a gamble as India yearns for a series-levelling triumph.

The discourse ahead of the Vizag Test is not just limited to potential debutants. The cricket fraternity echoes Parthiv’s assessment of India’s bowling strategy. The emphasis on spin over pace in subcontinent conditions is a narrative backed by successful historic precedents, raising the likelihood of Parthiv’s counsel resonating with the team’s decision-makers.

The debate surfaces at a time when cricket headlines include stories of Indian cricketer Mayank Agarwal’s hospitalization in Agartala due to illness, the U19 World Cup 2024 triumph led by Musheer Khan’s all-around heroics against New Zealand, and Uttar Pradesh government’s laudatory gesture of honoring star cricketer Deepti Sharma with a DSP post.

Team India, beset by injuries and facing strategic crossroads, stands at the cusp of a decision that may well shape the trajectory of the remaining series. As the cricket world’s gaze turns towards Vizag, anticipation mounts not just for the outcome of the Test, but for the strategies and combinations that India will deploy in pursuit of redemption.