In the creative landscape of modern cinema, Todd Phillips’ much-anticipated sequel, “Joker: Folie à Deux,” makes a bold return to the silver screen with an enigmatic infusion of classic theatrical elements and contemporary storytelling. It emulates the aura of Shakespeare’s timeless themes, particularly evoking shades of “Hamlet” through its complex lead, Arthur Fleck, played by the indomitable Joaquin Phoenix.
Arthur’s journey, which began in the critically acclaimed Joker (2019), sees him grappling with his inner demons and external challenges within the tumultuous confines of Arkham State Hospital. Having shocked the world with his brutal crimes, including the public assassination of television host Murray Franklin, Arthur finds himself in a psychological mire reminiscent of the melancholy Dane. His narrative shares the tragic depth of Hamlet’s—marked by a maternal betrayal that morphs into a vortex of frenzied violence and introspection.
The sequel opens two years after the catastrophic events that led to Arthur’s alter ego, the Joker, becoming a symbol of rebellion for the marginalized. These societal castaways were awakened to a new sense of justice, rallying around his chaotic philosophy. Now, Arthur is positioned as a pivotal player in his own trial, led by the politically savvy Assistant District Attorney Harvey Dent, portrayed with incisive ambition by Harry Lawtey. Dent’s motivations run deeper than pure justice; he seeks to amplify his public persona through the spectacle of Arthur’s trial.
Amidst this legal and moral chaos, Arthur navigates the intricate dynamics of Arkham, where he becomes a model inmate under the watchful eyes of the institution’s staff and fellow patients. It’s within these walls that Arthur encounters a paramour of sorts, Lee, played by pop icon Lady Gaga. Their meeting—inadvertently facilitated by a shared moment past the door of a music therapy class—kindles an instant, if not peculiar, bond. Lee, another soul shaped by neglect and institutionalization, reveals her own scars, having been abandoned after igniting her family home. This shared history of maternal trauma forges a profound and empathic connection between them.
.
As the plot unfolds, Lee’s determination manifests in a clandestine escape, driving an unexpected movement of support and solidarity that underscores her fierce loyalty to Arthur. Against this backdrop, the trial becomes not only a legal battle but also a conduit through which Arthur confronts the spectral fragments of his turbulent past. Characters like Sophie Dumond and Gary, illustrated vividly by Zazie Beetz and Leigh Gill, respectively, re-emerge, posing as ghosts of memory and imagination within Arthur’s fragmented psyche.
One of the film’s most intriguing facets is its musical dimension, an innovation reportedly prompted by Phoenix himself. Director Todd Phillips embraces this venture with both courage and finesse. The concoction of music and character work creates a mesmerizing theatre of sound and spectacle. The film’s beginning bursts with vibrant animation, setting a new tone without losing the core social dissonance that was starkly present in its predecessor. The musical score, composed by Hildur Guðnadóttir, invites viewers into a lush auditory experience, filling the theatre with reimagined classics that demand emotional investment.
Joaquin Phoenix continues to mesmerize, his gaunt frame and expressive face tell a tale that words fail to capture, balancing on the knife-edge between chaos and grace. His portrayal of Arthur leans towards an immersive exploration of the human condition, drawing parallels with Shakespearean monologues that dissect the dark and the transcendent. Meanwhile, Lady Gaga’s performance introduces a contrasting subtlety, shining through even without the manic energy associated with previous iterations like Margot Robbie’s Harley Quinn.
Though critics may argue that “Folie à Deux” lacks the intricate plotting of its predecessor, the film compensates with an exploratory vision of nuanced performances and lush cinematography by Lawrence Sher. The film’s pacing, especially in its latter half, might stumble yet watching Phoenix navigate this cinematic labyrinth remains a profound experience that engages and challenges its audience.
“Joker: Folie à Deux,” while currently screening in theatres, serves not just as a sequel but as an extension into the avant-garde, where music, madness, and philosophical inquiry converge into a filmic symphony.
