The climactic finale of The Rings of Power’s second season may have left several tantalizing questions unanswered and Upper Earth aficionados still yearning for more direct adherence to Tolkien’s original vision, but it undeniably achieved a feat far grander: it successfully transitioned from a costly entertainment gamble into a vibrant, immersive narrative that breathes life into the rich tapestry of Middle-earth. What began as a glossy and unpredictable attempt to rekindle the mystical allure of Tolkien’s universe has metamorphosed into something infused with depth, audacity, and notable self-assurance. Following a first season marred by its hesitance to embrace its grand potential, the showrunners have now boldly leaned into the expansive scale and inexhaustible lore of their source material. The culmination of this journey is not merely awe-inspiring; it resonates with the qualities of an epic crescendo.
Responding to the subdued critiques of its inaugural season, this second chapter undertakes a discernible course correction, evident in its grand finale. The first season had all the trappings of a spectacular TV experience — sweeping vistas, impeccable CGI, and the looming weight of Tolkien’s legacy. Yet, it often felt constricted by its grandeur, akin to a majestic bird held in a golden cage. With some clever influence from a surprisingly well-meaning Dark Lord, the series at last finds itself liberated from its self-imposed constraints.
Formerly peripheral characters and subplots begin to merge in meaningful ways, amplifying the central themes of power, corruption, and the seductive pull of darkness. Consequently, the narrative emerges more unified, even if there’s room for further refinement.
An intense highlight of the current season is how Sauron’s presence intensifies, expanding his shadow over Middle-earth. Charlie Vickers’s portrayal of Sauron as “the great deceiver” offers a masterclass in subversive villainy; a master manipulator concealing malice beneath a convincingly charming veneer. In contrast, Charles Edwards shines as Celebrimbor, a visionary driven by faith and ambition, yet tragically unaware of his impending doom. Their interactions portray a tragic dance of trust and betrayal, with Edwards’s nuanced unraveling perfectly complementing Vickers’s sinister allure. When Sauron’s true character is unveiled, it strikes not as a sudden blow but as a slow knife steadily carving its path throughout the season. The synergy between Vickers and Edwards elevates The Rings of Power into a psychological tragedy wrapped in epic stakes.
.
The sweeping, battle-laden conclusion delivers the anticipated spectacle, positioning the series ahead of most fantasy contenders. Whether witnessing the radiant conflict in war-torn Eregion or engaging with Durin’s Bane within the depths of Khazad-dûm, the visual execution of this finale is nothing short of spectacular. Yet, amidst the fire-laden battlefields and crumbling towers, it retains an emotional core, notably in the poignant yet fleeting relationship between Prince Durin IV (Owain Arthur) and his father, King Durin III. Their strained relationship, shaped by duty and stubborn pride, lends a touch of humanity to the high-stakes drama, even as a Balrog and the precious mithril mines threaten to eclipse their conflict.
While many fledgling narratives struggle in grounding their new fantasies in gritty authenticity, The Rings of Power revels in the luminescent splendour of Middle-earth. It invites the audience to relish in the sheer magical allure, from the ethereal lights of Valinor to the mesmerizing dance of reflection on molten mithril, evoking the weight of a history being unfurled. There’s an innate purity in this landscape, a refusal to dilute the magic for sake of appearing prestigious. Even when the story subtly falters, the grandeur remains unabated.
And herein lies the series’ treasure. Although The Rings of Power might not resonate with all, particularly those seeking the more mature tones of perhaps Westeros, it offers an alternative: a nostalgic return to when fantasy commanded an awe that transcended mere admiration. It beckons us to recall what it feels like to believe in the extraordinary, to lose ourselves in a realm where the eternal struggle between good and evil wages on, replete with beauty, danger, and unending thrill.
From the golden trees of Lindon to the expansive sands of Rhûn, The Rings of Power continuously captivates. Although not without its imperfections, notably the sidelined Harfoots who still feel detached from the main storyline, the show has matured significantly from its early missteps. While Sam Hazeldine’s Adar will be a missed presence, the series has carved its unique narrative space, independent yet still enchanted by the shadows of Middle-earth’s legendary narratives. It firmly reestablishes this world as one of wonder, peril, and irresistible enchantment — for which viewers can only be grateful.
All episodes of The Rings of Power are available to stream on Amazon Prime Video.
